Present Perfect vs. Simple Past: Rules, Examples and a Quiz

The present perfect vs. simple past question comes down to one thing: when. Use the simple past when you say or know the finished time ("I went to Chicago last year"). Use the present perfect when the time is not important or not finished, and the action connects to now ("I've been to Chicago twice"). The three steps below show you how, with audio examples and a six-question quiz at the end.
A quick reminder of the forms. The simple past is the past form of the verb: worked, went, saw. The present perfect is have or has plus the past participle: have worked, has gone, have seen. In speech, Americans almost always use the short form: I've, you've, she's, we've.
Step 1: simple past for a finished time
If the sentence has a finished time, like yesterday, last week, in 2020, two days ago or when I was a kid, use the simple past. The time is over, so the action is closed.
- I lost my wallet yesterday. Yesterday is a finished time, so the verb is simple past: lost.
- We moved to San Diego in 2020. In 2020 is over. You can't say "We have moved to San Diego in 2020."
- When did you start this job? Questions with when ask for a finished time, so they use did plus the base verb.
- She called me two hours ago. Ago always points to a finished time in the past, so it goes with the simple past.
Step 2: present perfect when the time isn't the point
Use the present perfect for life experiences and for past actions with a result now. You don't say when, because when isn't important. Words like ever, never, already, yet and just often come with it.
- Have you ever been to New York? Ever means at any time in your life. The question is about experience, not a date.
- I've never tried Ethiopian food. Never plus the present perfect: not at any time until now. Maybe you'll try it tomorrow.
- I've lost my keys. Can you help me look? The result is now: the keys are still lost. Compare: I lost my keys yesterday, but I found them.
- She's already finished the report. Already shows it happened before now, maybe sooner than expected. Here, she's means she has, not she is.
- Our team has worked with clients in 12 countries. Very common in job interviews and resumes: experience up to now, without a date.
Step 3: present perfect for things that are still true
Use the present perfect with for and since when something started in the past and is still true now. If it's over, go back to the simple past.
- I've lived in Houston for 6 years. I still live there. For plus a period of time: for 6 years, for a month, for a long time.
- Maria has worked here since 2021. Since plus the starting point: since 2021, since Monday, since I was 18.
- I lived in Manila for 10 years, and then I moved to Seattle. Now it's over: I don't live in Manila anymore. That's why it's simple past.
- How long have you known each other? How long plus the present perfect asks about something that is still true today.
Common mistakes
- "I have seen him yesterday." → I saw him yesterday. A finished time word always needs the simple past.
- "I live here since 2019." → I've lived here since 2019. With since, use the present perfect, not the present.
- "Did you ever saw snow?" → Have you ever seen snow? For life experience, the present perfect is the safe choice. (Some Americans say "Did you ever see...?" in casual talk, but never "did... saw.")
- "I have went." → I have gone. Use the past participle after have: gone, seen, eaten, written.
Can you use yesterday with the present perfect?
No. Yesterday, last week, in 2020 and ago are finished times, so they always take the simple past. This is the most common mistake for learners, especially if your first language uses one past tense for both. A good test: if you can answer the question "When?" with an exact time, use the simple past.
Do Americans use the present perfect less?
A little, in casual speech. Many Americans say "Did you eat yet?" or "I already did it," where British speakers prefer "Have you eaten yet?" and "I've already done it." Both are correct in American English. But with ever, never, for and since, Americans use the present perfect just like everyone else, so learn it well.
Quiz: present perfect or simple past?
Want 20 more questions? They're in our free PDF, with 60 everyday words and audio.
Ready for more? English Listening Workbook: 30 conversations with audio at two speeds, exercises and an answer key.
The present perfect shows up a lot in job interviews: "I've worked as a nurse for 5 years," "I've led a team of 8." See our job interview phrases to hear it at work, and review small words with our guide to in, on and at.